Review Policy

Reviews on Save The Banger come only from buyers who have dealt with the seller through the site. We publish every review that follows this policy, good or bad, and we never remove a review for being negative.

Who can review

Only a buyer who has dealt with a seller through Save The Banger can review them. A deal is:

  • an offer the seller accepted;
  • an auction the buyer won, including an offer to the highest or next highest bidder that they accepted;
  • a reservation that ended with the item sold to them;
  • a part sold to them by post.

A week after each deal, we email the buyer an invitation to review the seller. Every buyer gets the same invitation, whatever happened in the deal. They then have 60 days to leave a review: 1 to 5 stars and a short comment about the deal. There’s one review per deal.

A review must be the buyer’s own honest experience of that deal. Anyone connected to the seller, such as someone who works for them, a relative or a business partner, must not review them. We never pay or reward anyone for a review, and sellers mustn’t either.

How we check reviews

We take these steps to stop fake and misleading reviews:

  • Real deals only. A review can only follow a deal made through the site, and only the buyer in that deal can leave it.
  • One review per deal. A buyer can’t review the same deal twice.
  • Linked accounts checked. If the buyer’s and seller’s accounts look connected, for example because they share an address, a phone number or an internet connection, the review waits until we’ve checked it. We publish it only if we’re satisfied the accounts aren’t connected.
  • Checks for patterns. We look for signs of fake reviews, such as several new accounts reviewing the same seller, or deals that look as if they were made up to earn a review, and we investigate them.
  • Records. We keep a record of every review, every change to it and every removal, with the reason, so we can spot patterns and act on repeat problems.
  • Your reports. Anyone can report a review they think is fake or breaks this policy (see Reporting a review).

We assess the risk of fake reviews on the site, and check at least once a year that these steps are working.

How reviews are shown

  • Where: reviews appear on the seller’s page, newest first. The seller’s average star rating and number of reviews, such as “4.8 from 12 reviews”, appear next to their name on their ads.
  • What each review shows: the reviewer’s first name and initial (or business name, for a checked trader), the date, the kind of deal (such as “Bought a car” or “Bought a part”), the stars and the comment, with the seller’s reply if there is one.
  • Every review counts: we publish every review that follows this policy, good or bad. We never pick which reviews to show, and nobody can pay to change a seller’s reviews or rating. A Featured upgrade puts an ad higher in search results, but never changes its seller’s reviews.
  • How long: reviews are shown for 3 years. After that they’re removed, and the average and count are worked out again.
  • Keeping it accurate: when we remove a review, we work out the average and count again straight away.

What we remove, and what we never remove

We remove a review, or the part of it that breaks this policy, if it:

  • isn’t the reviewer’s own genuine experience of the deal, or was written by or for the seller;
  • was paid for or rewarded in any way, or was written by someone connected to the seller;
  • is about something other than the seller or the deal, such as another seller or the site itself;
  • is abusive, threatening, hateful or sexual, or harasses anyone;
  • includes personal information, such as an address, phone number, email address or vehicle registration;
  • includes links, or is advertising or spam;
  • is illegal, or encourages anything illegal;
  • states as fact something we’ve found to be untrue, such as a sale that didn’t happen.

We never remove a review because it’s negative, because the seller disagrees with it, or because the seller asks us to. A seller who disagrees with a review can reply to it.

When we remove a review, we tell the reviewer why. They can ask us to look at the decision again through our complaints process (section 11 of our Terms). A reviewer can also delete their own review at any time.

Sellers

  • Replying: a seller can reply once, publicly, under each review. Replies follow the same rules as reviews, and mustn’t include the buyer’s personal information.
  • No rewards: a seller must never offer anything for a review, such as money, a discount, a refund, a free extra or an entry into a prize draw.
  • No pressure: a seller must never pressure or threaten a buyer about a review, for example by threatening legal action. They must never make sorting out a problem depend on the buyer not leaving a review, or changing or deleting one.
  • No fake reviews: a seller must never review themselves, make up a deal to get a review, or ask staff, family or friends to review them.
  • Asking for reviews: a seller may remind a buyer that they can leave a review, but must ask every buyer in the same way, whatever happened in the deal.

If a seller breaks these rules, we may remove the reviews affected and correct their rating. We may also warn them, put a notice on their seller page saying we removed reviews that broke this policy, stop them selling for a time, or close their account. We may tell the Competition and Markets Authority or Trading Standards about serious or repeated breaches.

Reporting a review

Press “Report this review” under any review you think is fake or breaks this policy, and tell us why. We’ll look at it within 2 working days. While we look, the review stays up, unless it’s clearly abusive or illegal. We’ll tell you what we decided.

A review isn’t a complaint. If something has gone wrong with a deal, contact the seller first. Report anything illegal or unsafe with “Report this ad” or “Report this conversation”. To complain about us, see section 11 of our Terms.

Comments on ads

Comments under ads are for questions and answers about the item. They aren’t reviews, and they don’t count towards a seller’s rating. To review a seller, use the invitation we send after a deal.

The rules for comments are in section 15 of our Terms. Phone numbers, email addresses and links are hidden automatically. Offers made in comments don’t count, so use “Make offer to buy” instead. A seller can hide a comment on their own ad if it breaks the rules, but not just because it’s critical. The person who wrote it is told, and can ask us to put it back.

Your information

Our Privacy Notice explains how we use the information in reviews and comments, and how long we keep it.

Scroll to Top